Can love make a person stray from his/her personal legend?

by Paulo Coelho on November 16, 2007

40% of the emails that I receive come from people that say that they had to renounce their dream for love.
Personally, I don’t think love can make a person stray from his/her personal legend.
What do you think?
Love
Paulo

Previous post:

Next post:

{ 98 comments }

ivan November 19, 2007 at 8:28 pm

Hi all,

I think that only when we allow love to take us away from our dreams or path, we can say that we are not sure of what we really want or consider our dream.
When some one is fallowing his/hers dreas not even love can break your dreams or path.
We need to be able to come to understand that love is a gift that we all have within our self, our truth path or dream in this life is revial to us a long the way, have the courage to walk together with both and life will open it arms to you.

if92

Julieann November 19, 2007 at 8:09 pm

I believe that it is as simple as a quote from a song I love…’Without love in the dream it will never come true’…and vise versa. If I believed that dreams were to be sacrificed for love and love sacrificed for dreams it would deteriorate the entire structure of why I believe we are given them to begin with.

the moderator November 19, 2007 at 4:39 pm

she lives a happy life
is plain for all to see
so don’t pull your hair out
for what you only think you see -

a girl lost or stuck or free
a woman starved by sexuality
the baby so tender & so lovalie

is but reflection of you and

them -

not me!

the fluctuator November 19, 2007 at 4:34 pm

the man of steel stands
closer to the cotton field
when life is hard
to feel the soft & susceptible…

the young girl of tender heart
stands nearer the construction site
as she takes in the pounding with wonder
also sympathetic plight

i don’t know the secret language
and i don’t see how it might
help me get through the night.

stefan November 19, 2007 at 1:39 pm

…a lovely moment that rumble
through naked streets of life
is knocking on my broken door
as a shadow of someone I’ve yet to meet.

I do know one secret language,
that leads to your heart, she said.
those are words without letters
I gently whisper to myself…

stefan

fussy November 19, 2007 at 1:34 pm

you dont have to change your dreams because of love…
dreams is part of ourselves, these is who we are.. love is makes life more meaningful and we can be a better person. because it complete us…

karen- November 19, 2007 at 10:22 am

I think that love can make ouselves better, it’s true, but what love can make this? only true love, the love that leave ourselves free, the love that know and accept ourselves.

Yajna November 19, 2007 at 1:17 am

Natita,

I admire your relationship and i can understand how you love. Personally i’m similar. I love such the man of my dreams follows his own dreams. Thing is, when u love someone so deeply all you really want is their happiness. If they have a dream, their dream suddenly becomes your dream as well, but for them. Like i honestly wish with all my heart that he reaches his dreams- i suppose mainly because when we love them , we know who they are, and we truely believe in them like no others. Love shouldn’t take you away from your personal legend but should be a tool to always guide you and motivate you to strive for them. I’m not saying it will be easy always to love and find your way in this world- i’m just saying you should try, and never give up. I admire both of you and wish you both all of the best:)

Aditya

Well, the whole HIV needle prick injury is still a bit of a worry but its all about being careful and preventing it. I really do love what i’m studying and i’ll find away to get around it somehow :)

Lots of love
Yajna

Jennifer November 18, 2007 at 11:02 pm

I believe that if you do follow your heart, which is in essence following your dream, you will find that your dream is interconnected with love. And the romantic love that will come into your life, if it is the right situation for you, will work to keep you on the right path and support you through trying and difficult times. The love is a component of the dream. If you feel like you must choose between the two, then you should always choose the dream as it will never lead you astray. True love will never ask you to part with your dream.

Nefertiti November 18, 2007 at 10:46 pm

My ego has lamented of her despair of the lack and loss of romantic love for all of this lifetime. Ego was trying to convince me that I was not worthy of love or of a fulfilling life expression. The Divine ‘I AM’ that has integrated into my human beingness has taught me that I AM Love and I am to court Love, just as I would court a beloved human lover. This love that I am courting is taking me into the depths of my humanness and the heights of my divine nature. I am tapping into levels of soul expression that I may never have, had I remained in the pit of ego’s illusionary despair. I journey with Love through the light and the darkness and always experience Truth in my awareness; that it is all Love and is always there. Blessings

Francisco Estevam November 18, 2007 at 8:35 pm

Hello Paulo_my favourite writer!!!!
Well, I don’t think real love might stray somebody from their personal legend. Certainly passion may do that. My life has proved it that love does take you back to your personal legend instead.I was living a completely bleak life with no encouraging future perspectives at all. And just then I met this girl when I was hanging out with my friends. When I started talking to her it felt like the whole world had stopped spinning.It was really love at first sight.That had never happened to me before. There were a lot of people where we were but I didn’t take any notice of them. It felt like they weren’t there at all. We never had no kind of love relationship but on the following day I wrote a song to her as I was learning how to play the guitar and I wrote it in English and my English teacher realised that I might have talent to teach English as I wrote the song without mistakes. And then, he got me a job as an English teacher at a private English school. Since then my professional life has been inexorably improving. It’s been six years since that night. I loved that girl so much that words cannot describe it but she never loved me back, only as a friend and always understood what I felt about her. It’s been almost a year since I last talked to her as she doesn’t live anymore in my town. She came into my life, unconsciously changed it for the better and went away. Now, I’m sure about what my personal legend is. And I’m walking on this path, only because one day I felt real love!!! Peace and Health may be with you Paulo!!! byebye

donna November 18, 2007 at 8:05 pm

I see a contradiction in the statement posted by Satya….”love has nothing to do with one’s dreams. Love is always unconditional.” If love is unconditional then why is there the condition imposed separating love from dream?

Leina Wald November 18, 2007 at 6:43 pm

I think love and our personal way goes hand in hand. Everything is in order in this life: where we are going, where we are living, the people we meet also the people we love. If it is real and true love there will be always a way for our personal dreams for the future, our interests and also our love we wanna live.
But sometimes we only think that we are sure about our dreams and interests.But often it is not right. Often we just find out our real way by going different ways. Sometimes the person we love shows us different ways. It is a present of this life.

Tania Chilby November 18, 2007 at 2:57 pm

Hi Paulo,
Just new to this site,and doing my blog page and came across your page,in answer to this I believe that we can have it all, once you truly love yourself ,you will be not needy,thus your passionate life will be filled with the perfect partner,perfect health,wealth and so forth and of course as you are one with god ,you are one with your truth,now that indeed is all you will ever need.I am on myspace as well !I write healing cards and poems and have just completed 2 books ,
Blessings Tania

brightlightwarriornika November 18, 2007 at 2:31 pm

Isn’t all about bringing your two worlds together as one?

Love + Dream = personal legend?

For we (warriors) know that there is no impossible.

Nuno Firmino November 18, 2007 at 1:07 pm

Três coisas são capazes de nos afastar do nosso caminho pessoal, mas a mais significativa é, sem dúvida, a baixa auto estima.

Namrata November 18, 2007 at 9:59 am

Dear Paulo,

I have read all your books and “The Alchemist” remains an all time favourite. The book “The fifth mountain” seems to be so much my story that I cried while reading it and felt much better after that. I have loved and lost. And I feel that love doesnt in anyway hamper your dreams because love is all about keeping the other person and his/her happiness first. I dont think it is difficult to manage both as I have seen people do that with ease.
I would say keep loving and keep dreaming too!!!

Deepa Rani November 18, 2007 at 8:52 am

Everything you imagine is real. Somewhere I read, everything is possible in this world, just we need to see the things in different angle, think out of the box.

Real love certainly exists and so does God. Just we should have enough dare to accept it, believe on it….

Yudi November 18, 2007 at 5:11 am

Pienso que si una persona dice que renunció a sus sueños por amor es que sus sueños nunca fueron, al menos en su mente, lo suficientemente fuertes para concretarse…así que la persona termina echandole la culpa al amor cuando la única o el único culpable lo fue la falta de valentía para luchar por sus sueños.

Zita November 18, 2007 at 2:51 am

Si algo se del amor es, nada. Pero he aprendido especialmente despues de leer el alquimista que los suenos son los deseos puros del corazon, y con mi experiencia ersonal; que los verdaderos suenos son los suenos de Dios…y se cumplen.Quiza no he sonado en el amor de un hombre y asi hoy, me siento realizada y plena, no se manana pero hoy estoy y feliz. Tengo 2 divorcios y tres hijos, no siento que he fracasado sino que he aprendido..esa es mi leyenda personal..sigo buscando mi mision; y como dice San Agustin: “Buscar es encontrar”.

huff-puff November 18, 2007 at 2:37 am

Paulo here’s what i don’t get…

if one can make another happy, fulfilled and free, when he is away better than when he is present, why would he make the effort to be present?

if someone is need-less, and who doesn’t appear to need anything (or seems to have everything she needs), why would anyone have the urge to be with them?

if i love people, why on earth am i so hard on myself?!?!?! and maybe on others too…?!?!?!

reet November 17, 2007 at 11:34 pm

I don’t think love could stray you from your personal legend.Love, i think is a personal legend in itself . Its hard to separate the two if they both consume your life with the same intensity. You dont have to give up one for another however, even if you acheieve one of the two in this lifetime, it should be enough to give you the peace in life.

Shweta November 17, 2007 at 10:10 pm

I think there is a price to pay for your dreams.The price and stake at times are very high at times but it is worth taking. Personally, what i feel is there is a time for everything, one period of time your dreams are so important to you that nothing can come in between not even love but there will be one moment in life when love is so supreme that nothing compares to it and nothing is so supreme than your love.

julie November 17, 2007 at 9:55 pm

I am one of the 40% who had to give up their dream for love. here is my story.

I love my daughters who are 8 and 11 years old but I do not love their father, yet we have been together for over 16 years. there is no love between me and my husband yet I have to be with him becasue I feel that my girls need a stable family with a mother and a father.

I dream of being in love with another man, I dream of the day when my girls are older and I will be able to find the love of my life. yet, the older I get the more I realize that life is so short and chances are that I may never experience love in my life again. I was in love once in my life with a man when I was 18 years old. we were together for 5 years, but could not marry. so, I married my husband whom I was not in love with in order to have a family of my own.

so in my case you could say that I had to give up being in love with a man for my dream of having a family. and I had to give up my dream of being in love with a man for the love I feel for my girls.

also what kind of love are we talking about here? the love between a man and woman or the love between a mother and her child? or love in itself?

Donna November 17, 2007 at 7:57 pm

If it is real love then it shouldn’t separate you from your dream. If it is true love it should bring you closer to your personal legends.

mariangela November 17, 2007 at 6:07 pm

Acho que quando um homem e uma mulher casam-se fizeram a escolha do amor. Que é maior que o amor?
Acho que não há renúncia do sonho, se o próprio é o motivo da escolha.Isso não quer dizer que não existam outros, que independe, da união.
Acho que a mulher deve acompanhar o marido, não por obrigatoriedade; mas pela própria escolha de seu principal sonho : ele.
Beijos,
Mari Raphael.

Satya November 17, 2007 at 6:07 pm

Love has nothing to do with one’s dreams. Love is always unconditional. It is not material. When you love a person you love a living being, the life in the being and not a concept, or an extension of your likes. The same thing applies to the other person being loved. There are sacrifices.

Donna November 17, 2007 at 5:25 pm

If a person loves you then your dream is part of who you are, part of what makes you unique. Your dream is simply part of what they love about you. If there is a rift between love and dream, I wonder….do they really love you? Or do they simply need something you have that will strengthen them?

Tanja November 17, 2007 at 3:58 pm

Sabéis que, a mí me parece que la gente que abandona su sueño, lo hace porque no cree profundamente que puede cumplirlo y además no tiene suficiente curage y confianza en sí mismo. Y además se siente más protegido sí lo hace por amor. Así, tiene una excusa y puede decir que se ha sacrificado. También me ocurrió que otra rason puede ser esa, que la persona que abandona un sueño lo hace inconscientemente, creyendo que es mejor hacer cosas ¨que son más útiles¨ en algun momento de su vida, y que en futuro tendrá más tiempo por su sueño. Pero cómo tiempo pasa es más difícil encontrar el momento adecuado para dedicarse a tu sueño.
Pienso que, el amor es lo más importante en nuestras vidas, nuestros sueños también(también representan nuestro amor), y tenemos que encontrar maneras para unir los dos. Sí perdemos uno de estos dos, no seremos felices y completos. Siempre tendremos impresión que nos falta algo.
Vive l´amour! :)
Saludos cordiales:*
Tanja:)

July November 17, 2007 at 7:02 am

El amor alimenta mis sueños. Mis sueños alimentan mi alma.

je suis du sud November 17, 2007 at 4:00 am

For me, Love is an exchange between souls.

Marie-Christine

Mihaï November 17, 2007 at 3:36 am

We always need to equilibrate what we give with what we receive.

Love is what we give.

Dreams of passion is what we want to receive.

Jeremy November 16, 2007 at 11:46 pm

All of the responses are so well thought out and deep, some complex and some so simple. I almost didn’t want to post anything in fear of sounding silly.
If one has a to abandon a dream in the name of love or another persons dream, it seems to me that a greater love must exist for the person who is contemplating giving up their dream. Possibly love in such a case is not real or perhaps there is a greater love out there for that person only to be found by following his or her dream(s). I’d like to think that my dreams will lay out a path to love.

Leaf November 16, 2007 at 9:02 pm

I haven’t had time to read all through these comments, but most agree, it seemss, that Love and the personal legend are entwined.
I would say that that is because, as god/Life is Love, and that the greatest Life manifests most Love, the personal path/legend is god given…are one and the same, and it is only when we look at a ‘person’ whom we may love, and still disagree with, to give up the legend, then that is an act of limiting god and life and love to just one manifestation…and it is not true/real love, which is found in the whole of humanity, and the natural world, not just in our favourite husband/wife/partner….and whereas, the other side of the coin is just as valid, it may sow us that either the path we are on is not the path we were meant for, or that we have been distracted by a mere person, taking us away from the whole. xx

Natita November 16, 2007 at 8:21 pm

I’m a 21 years old young women who lives in Argentina, and think that if you really are in love with someone you would let him/her follow his/her dream no matter what it takes.
Four years ago the person I’m in love with had to leave the conuntry and go to Switzerland to follow his dream. I was 17 and he was 19, we were the best friends all over the world, and we were also in love with each other. In fact, we still are.
I’ve suffered a lot during this time,
sometimes I missed him so badly that I didn’t know what to do, I just needed a hugh, a kiss, all the things a machine can not give you. Some other times I just wanted to tell him: “It’s over, let’s move on with our lifes, I can’t live like this anymore”. But then I remebered everything we’ve been thruogh, how much do I love him, how much he means to me and I realized that was just an easy way out to scape from the fear and the pain. If I had done that nowadays we wouldn’t be together.
Next year will be our seventh aniversary; we’re celebrating seven years “together” of wich four we’ve been apart just to follow our dreams.
So if you ask me, I definitely don’t think love can make you stray from your personal legend.

Tarek November 16, 2007 at 8:14 pm

dear paulo coelho
i can see u appreciate the art of the lebanese poet jibran Khalil jibran well am proud to tell you that am a lebanese and jibran khalil jibran is an inspirational figure for me. well when Al mustapha was asked in the book “the prophet” by jibran ” about love he answered “For even as love crowns you so shall he crucify you. Even as he is for your growth so is he for your pruning. ” he also adds “Love has no other desire but to fulfil itself.” well i guess if you check other books for jibran you would understand that the love that jibran talked about was a utopian divine love , and even this love would cause you to suffer because again as jibran says “love posses not nor need to be possesed” so i would say that love is a human feelings hence it can never be absolute, so for humans their only exists moment of love, and even no matter how short these experiences would be one should give up all his dreams and desires to experience it , and again as jibran says :”
“But if you love and must needs have desires, let these be your
desires:
To melt and be like a running brook that sings its melody to the night.
To know the pain of too much tenderness.
To be wounded by your own understanding of love;
And to bleed willingly and joyfully.
To wake at dawn with a winged heart and give thanks for another day
of loving;
To rest at the noon hour and meditate love’s ecstasy;
To return home at eventide with gratitude;
And then to sleep with a prayer for the beloved in your heart and a
song of praise upon your lips.”

fLUXman November 16, 2007 at 7:04 pm

bo0om paulo,;->
love felt so complete,
personal , whats that???
legend , my dreams,my wings no my,,,
found a four leaf clover and ate it,
my heart still throbs for that completeness,
that i felt with her on our sunrise walks,
soulmate, thought i , maybe it was the future, may be the past.
love oh love, much more did i learn from my three daughters.
felt my heart forget itself in selflessness.
what am i waiting for, wanting???
its beyond nothing , its a rhythm of evolution.
minds flying together, dont you feel him too,
a universal vibration, tears in our eyes,
love
bo0om
fLUXman

Kathleen November 16, 2007 at 7:01 pm

I believe your fate will always seek you out, if not sooner, then later. I once thought I had given up my dream for love, but it jumped up and and we flew away together in later years.
Of course, if someone tries to hold you back from your dreams, they don’t really love you, they just want to control you..a heady feeling many enjoy and call love.
REal love gives plenty of space. Maybe not always support…one may have to look outside to friendships and other relations for that, but freedom, certainly.

CordieB November 16, 2007 at 6:37 pm

I agree with Debra above. Love does not demand what it does not have and love doesn’t force itself on others in order to feel better about itself. Whatever is not an expression of love is an expression of fear.

Esteban November 16, 2007 at 3:36 pm

I think people should realize that your personal legend includes love. you can have it all. just have to be creative at times. find solutions to make things work.

Tracy November 15, 2007 at 11:09 pm

I think it depends on if a person believes that their love needs to be recipricated in order to love someone. When I decided to love my husband I decided it would be for all time no matter what our personal struggles may be where we may be and reguardless of his response. Mind you I did not make this decision truly until we had been married several years. I believe that relationships are about self growth and have nothing to do with where the other person is in their journey. So when you love someone you accept them as they are dreams and all.

Joy Calosa November 15, 2007 at 9:40 pm

It’s just sad that…

Well, love goes on, as Mr. Paulo Coelho says in By the River Piedra…

The well stays even if the people who dug it moved…

Suhaim November 15, 2007 at 6:33 pm

My personal legend isn’t my dream, and I renounced my love for it.

Annette November 15, 2007 at 5:20 pm

Is the love only in a partner present? I find the love begin in each humans with the birth. We are all love. Why do humans do without the love to live it to experience it to assume? Why can we give or take only love if the dream partner steps into our life?
Am I wrong even if I live love in my everyday life, in my environment, with my job? There do I really ask myself, how love defined? May love be lived only if physical juices exchange takes place? Why do humans make the love so complicated? It is nevertheless the simplest thing of the world. In all our veins flows not only blood, but indescribably much love, which is more than only the love between partners.

Rosalie November 15, 2007 at 11:48 am

Dear Paolo,
I think that love is the sun on the way to your dream.You can’t always feel it, but it is always there. And sometimes is the sun the answere in witch way to go on your way.
I wish you and the people who read this a sunny day!
Rosalie

Fou November 15, 2007 at 8:47 am

Dear Paulo,

I think that nothing should make you stray from your dreams. I also believe that one chooses his or her legend. Therefore, my personal choice would be to have bigger dreams. Ones which include all things and people that can make me happy. Why restricting yourself? If anything, a lifetime seems to me not enough to taste at all beautiful things in this world. Another lifetime would be even far from enough to tell the tale… As you might know better than anyone, Paulo. :)

Fou

aditya November 15, 2007 at 8:38 am

Paulo !
A NOBLE EXCUSE :-)
that’s just an excuse, a noble one !!

afraid of failure we soon quit trying to pursue our dreams ! and then we look for excuses, love seems to be a good scapegoat !

Nataliya November 15, 2007 at 5:57 am

What is love if not a dream of a kind? Since childhood, we’ve been fed the “happily ever after” fairytale–that love will come and we’ll be forever happy. So when people say that they rescind their dream for their love, I think they are simply replacing one dream with another one, so the dream of having a partner or a family may sometimes replace the dream of self-realization. Yet, I don’t think that love itself makes the person rescind the non-love-related dream–some people simply give up. I’ve seen a few people who have decided that they would not get where they wanted to go and settled for less–and “love” in the package of the family and kids comes as a convenient excuse to stop fighting for old goals. Then, again, perhaps, to some, old goals and dreams simply become less important. So, I believe that it’s simply a matter of choice–and for someone about to give up anyway, love often offers a good way out of a fight for a dream.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: